A new report by the aviation consultancy Baines Simmons shows that concerns about pilot fatigue in Europe have changed very little since 2023. The report, A fatigue survey of European Pilots – 2026, is based on a survey of 7,200 European pilots. It shows that microsleeps in the cockpit, insufficient rest and reluctance to report fatigue continue to be problems. This raises questions about airline safety cultures and about regulatory oversight.
Fatigue reporting remains a challenge
According to the survey, 76.8% of pilots had at least one microsleep while operating an aircraft in the four weeks before the survey. In addition, 38.8% said they usually or always do not have enough rest to prevent cumulative fatigue.
The pilots were also asked what they normally do when fatigue makes them unfit to fly. Only 37.2% said they report it, while 24.2% said they do not report it and fly fatigued anyway. Many pilots see airline reporting systems as ineffective or not trustworthy. Some continue to fly while fatigued because they fear a negative reaction from management. In the free-text answers, 38.2% of pilots mentioned fear of punishment or retaliation from management after a fatigue report. Another 46.9% said they had flown fatigued because they were worried about how management would react, and 44% did not want to attract attention to themselves.
Capt. Tanja Harter, President of the European Cockpit Association (ECA), said that if the industry is serious about managing the safety risks of pilot fatigue, the figures, and the lack of real improvement over three years, are a clear wake-up call for airlines, authorities and EASA. In her view, something must change in the way Europe deals with pilot fatigue. She also called on airlines and national authorities to act, arguing that pilots cannot be left to manage the problem alone while they operate flights.
Pressure to extend flight duties
The report also looks at Commander's Discretion (CD), which normally allows a flight duty to be extended in exceptional circumstances. In the four weeks before the survey, 38.3% of the pilots had used it at least once, and 15.2% had used it twice or more.
Concern about refusing to extend a duty has grown. In 2026, 69.1% of pilots said they were concerned to some degree about refusing to use Commander's Discretion. In 2023 the figure was 65.8%. The concern was highest among pilots working for low-cost operators and ACMI or wet-lease operators, and for airlines with Air Operator Certificates (AOCs) in Ireland and Malta. It was lowest in Germany and the Netherlands.
Capt. Coen George, an ECA Board Director, said that this "fear factor" raises questions about the safety culture at some airlines, because no pilot should fly when fatigued. He explained that when pilots worry that reporting fatigue could harm their careers, they stop reporting it. This may keep an airline's fatigue statistics clean for the next authority inspection, but it moves the risk back into the cockpit. The airline then cannot see how big its safety risks really are. George also pointed to pressure on pilots to extend duties to make up for delays or schedules that are too optimistic, and to the risk of reprimands for refusing. He said the ECA has repeatedly warned aviation authorities about these practices and is still waiting for meaningful action.
Differences between countries and operators
The survey found big differences in how pilots experience fatigue risk management in Europe. As in 2023, Ireland and Malta were among the lowest-ranked countries in most of the areas examined. Finland and the Netherlands ranked well above the other countries.
The report says that safety culture and non-punitive CD processes are implemented differently across AOC countries and operator types. It also says that the differences in concern about refusing CD show a weakness in safety culture. Europe introduced the principle of Just Culture into aviation regulation in 2014, but the report suggests that some operators are still not consistent in following safety-culture principles, especially in fatigue management.
Ian Holder, Managing Director of Baines Simmons, said the survey shows how European pilots experience fatigue risk management in practice. He explained that it is based on pilots' own accounts and is not a direct measure of risk or safety outcomes, which must be assessed in other ways. However, he said that the results have been consistent over three years and that they differ between countries and operator types. In his view, this shows operators and authorities where to focus their efforts. Holder added that the results from Finland and the Netherlands show that a stronger reporting culture is possible.
What this means for airlines and regulators
The findings point to a gap between formal fatigue-management procedures and what pilots report. Airlines need reporting systems that crews trust and can use without fear of punishment. Without reliable reporting, operators may not be able to see how much fatigue there is in their operations or what patterns it follows. Operational planning also matters: pressure to extend duties, for example because of delays or schedules, can affect whether pilots feel able to refuse an extension. National aviation authorities should check how fatigue procedures work in practice, and not rely only on the existence of formal policies.
EASA review
The report comes while the European Union Aviation Safety Agency (EASA) is finishing its Best Intervention Strategy on Aircrew Fatigue, which will set priorities for the coming years. EASA's own scientific research has already produced recommendations for changes to its Flight Time Limitation regulations. The new survey also matches trends in EASA's recent Article 89 report on the safety impact of socio-economic factors. That report found that, across all its evidence, aircrew fatigue was the clearest and most consistent signal. It also identified fatigue as the fastest-growing and largest safety precursor in the ECR occurrence database. It was present in almost 60% of safety-precursor-related occurrences in 2024.
Harter said the findings should lead to changes in how airlines manage fatigue risks and how national authorities supervise operators. She called for stronger EASA regulations, proactive fatigue risk management, and enforcement of non-punitive fatigue reporting and of the use of Commander's Discretion. The report concludes that the problems have been identified, and it calls for action instead of waiting another three years for a new assessment.
